The Conversation: "Quantum 'Wall-Walker': A New Experiment on the Tunnel Effect Reignites the Debate on the Interpretation of Quantum Physics"

Search
October 29, 2026
Waves or particles? For those seeking greater ontological clarity, check out Broglie's theory. Myteamart/Shutterstock (no reuse)
Waves or particles? For those seeking greater ontological clarity, check out Broglie's theory. Myteamart/Shutterstock (no reuse)
Long-term stays in space have an impact on astronauts’ immune systems. In particular, they lead to the reactivation of viruses that remain dormant in their bodies.

The Essentials

  • Quantum mechanics emerged about a hundred years ago. Since then, it has led to numerous technological advances, including LEDs, MRI scans, and lasers. But its interpretation remains puzzling to novices and a subject of debate among specialists, particularly philosophers.
  • At the time, Louis de Broglie, a French physicist, had proposed an interpretation that was initially ridiculed but was later rediscovered as a viable alternative.
  • A recent article in the journal *Nature* describes an elegant experiment, which the authors interpret as proof that de Broglie was wrong. Other experts, backed by their calculations, refute this conclusion.

Almost a century ago, at the Fifth Solvay Conference in Brussels, modern quantum mechanics was born. Two worldviews clashed there.

On one side is the Copenhagen school, led by the Dane Niels Bohr—the inventor of the first atomic model with quantized orbits—and by the Germans Werner Heisenberg and Max Born, the architects of its mathematical formalism. For them, the world is inherently random, governed by chance and probability, and cannot be understood using our usual concepts of space, time, and causality.

On the other hand, Albert Einstein defended the classical “determinism” of Newton and Laplace, according to which every object follows a precise trajectory through space and time, determined solely by its initial conditions. This debate, summed up by Einstein’s quip, “God does not play dice,” has become legendary.

We tend to forget that a third option was proposed at that same conference by the French aristocrat and physicist Louis de Broglie. Although long disparaged and even disavowed by de Broglie himself, this explanation still stands up to experimental testing today.

The Third Way at the 1927 Solvay Conference

As early as 1923, Louis de Broglie had the revolutionary insight to associate a wave with each electron, thereby attributing a dual nature (that is, both wave and particle) to matter in order to explain Bohr’s quantized atomic orbits. Shortly thereafter, in 1926, Schrödinger derived the mathematical equation for this wave.

A direct consequence of this quantum duality is that, just as with light, we can conduct an interference experiment—known as the “double-slit experiment”— by sending electrons one at a time, like marbles, through two closely spaced slits in a screen. Even when fired one at a time, the electrons eventually produce alternating light and dark bands on a wall—a pattern typical of waves, which at certain points reinforce each other through addition (light bands) and at other points cancel each other out through subtraction (dark bands).

How could a particle that must pass through one slit be influenced by the other slit, which it did not pass through? For Bohr and his colleagues at the Copenhagen School, this mystery was inexplicable in terms of classical trajectories: it is a bit like someone being able to pass through two doors at the same time. It is, of course, also inexplicable in terms of a pure wave, since we clearly see localized flashes on the screen—signs of the electron’s particle-like nature.

This justified their skepticism toward Broglie’s ideas, which they considered archaic and backward. Indeed, in their view, one had to be more revolutionary and abandon any classical conception of space-time: electrons are neither particles nor waves, but something else entirely, which could not be fully captured by these two complementary representations of reality.

It’s worth noting that Schrödinger, in fact, attempted to take this logic to its extreme and completely eliminate the particle to retain only the wave: this is known as “wave mechanics.” But that would have been like throwing the baby out with the bathwater: without a particle, we can no longer explain the localized detection of electrons on a screen. An electron appears here or there, not here and there at the same time. We definitely need both concepts.

Louis de Broglie's Quantum Surfer

It was to address this dilemma that Broglie presented his pilot-wave theory to Solvay. Unlike the Copenhagen interpretation and unlike Schrödinger’s wave-only theory, it retains—as in Newton’s theory—point particles with real, continuous trajectories.

The image is intuitive: the particle is guided by the Broglie-Schrödinger quantum wave, like a surfer riding a wave. It passes through only one slit, but the wave passes through both and guides it.

When the experiment is repeated many times, the trajectories of the electrons differ slightly due to different initial conditions. In the end, statistically speaking, interference fringes appear naturally, without any magic. The mystery of wave-particle duality disappears.

This theory was strongly criticized by Bohr’s colleagues, who saw it as a return to the notion of a trajectory—a concept they considered outdated and even abandoned by Broglie himself, likely for fear of being marginalized. It did not resurface until 1952, when it was rediscovered by the American David Bohm. Today it is known as the “Broglie-Bohm theory, ” or dBB theory.

As Bohm has shown, we now know that the objections raised by the Copenhagen school were unfounded, and dBB theory is recognized as a perfectly coherent alternative.

For experts in the field, it is even the natural culmination of this line of thought: it clarifies quantum measurement and resolves paradoxes such as that of Schrödinger’s famous cat, which is both dead and alive (to put it simply, in this theory, the existence of trajectories allows electrons—just like cats—to be “here or there,” rather than “here and there”).

Inside the Quantum Wall: The Revenge of the Trajectories

However, dBB theory is regularly put to the test. Last year, a paper by Jan Klaers’ Dutch team, published in the prestigious journal *Nature*, caused quite a stir by appearing to cast doubt on the theory.

Their argument centers on the “tunnel effect,” a quintessentially quantum experiment, much like the double-slit experiment.

The tunnel effect is a phenomenon in which a particle passes through an obstacle that is normally impassable—such as a wall, for example. In quantum mechanics, this passage is made possible by an evanescent wave that seeps through the barrier.

Klaers' team carried out this experiment with elegance, using photons—particles of light—to pass through a microbarrier fabricated in the laboratory, and succeeded in photographing the evanescent waves under a microscope. The experiment is beautiful and remarkable.

It is the interpretation that raises questions: according to the authors, the dBB theory would predict a velocity of zero inside the barrier, preventing any passage. This contradiction would, at first glance, seem to refute the theory. We will see that this is not the case.

The crux of the paradox is actually very simple. In optics, dBB theory is simply the translation into trajectories of Maxwell’s equations—dating back to the late 19th century—which describe the behavior of light. The trajectories trace the propagation of light energy throughout the entire apparatus, from the source in front of the barrier to the camera behind the microscope. This energy flow is associated with a velocity, and a colleague and I have shown that it is exactly the velocity predicted by dBB.

The conclusion is clear: if a signal is detected behind the barrier, as is the case here, it means that energy—and therefore dBB trajectories—has indeed passed through. Far from refuting the theory, Klaers’ experiment actually illustrates it.

Together with two colleagues from the Technion (Israel Institute of Technology), Dustin Lazarovici and Bernard Nabet, we conducted a quantitative analysis of this phenomenon. To image the evanescent field, Klaers’s device relies on minute leaks of light. It was precisely the effect of these leaks on the dBB trajectories that had been overlooked in their analysis. Once the actual optical properties were taken into account, the contradiction disappeared: contrary to what Klaers and his colleagues had predicted, the dBB velocity is no longer zero within the barrier; the trajectories do indeed pass through it. The theory then agrees perfectly with the observations and gives them full meaning. Our results were published this year in the same journal, in response to the initial paper.

What can we conclude? First, that dBB theory is robust and holding up well, despite repeated attacks. It reproduces all the predictions of standard quantum mechanics.

The only real debates concern the boundaries of quantum mechanics itself: quantum field theory, where particles appear and disappear—which would require an extension of dBB to include trajectories that begin and end—or quantum gravity and cosmology, which seek to unify quantum mechanics and Einstein’s general relativity. Numerous attempts inspired by dBB have been made in this direction.

The dBB theory will undoubtedly continue to spark debate, but its explanatory power—based on a clear description and set of axioms regarding trajectories—remains immense for anyone who wants to dispel the mystery and ambiguity of traditional quantum mechanics.The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Readthe original article.
Published on 29 October 2026
Updated on 29 October 2026